Joe, It takes time and effort but if you truly enjoy this piano, refinish it. I refinished an upright and currently I am working on turning an old piano case into a music workstation. If you do it yourself you can be assured that you will use the right materials and that you will not have to touch it again for decades....
Here is a link to a picture of the piano I refinished, maybe it can provide some inspiration:
http://mhestnes.brinkster.net/Piano/piano_old.htm