Petrof/Weinbach: what are the distinctions?

We were considering Samick or Young Chang 5' baby grands but have 80% or so decided that these may not be inspiring or rich enough pianos. The idea was to go from Samick to in a few years Petrof and then something on the more elite scale afterwards. But the Petrof feels much more rich and inspiring for the various types of Classical (in the general sense as opposed to period) and modern music that we will play on it. The Petrov V has good reviews in Larry Fine's book as well as good caveats for the marque. So we've raised the bar and will want the Petrof for awhile and then upgrade to possibly a fine German brand considerably further into the future.

What I'm not clear on, however, is the distinction of Petrof and Weinbach. So my question for those familiar with these instruments, both performers and technicians, is what are the differences? I feel there must be a difference as Weinbachs are a bit lower priced than Petrov. Are these cosmetic differences in terms of quality of finish and cosmetic materials or are there functional materials that may affect durability, consistency of tones and other important factors.

As always, Thanks. We received some helpful info in the Entry Leve Baby Grand thread. Also we have decided on this piano (Petrof V or comparable Weinbach) and are not considering a used piano or an upright. Maybe besides our better judgment and the fine advice of members of this forum but a new 5' 2' to 5' 4' is what we are set on getting.

Ben Smith

Strictly cosmetics. Cork

No matter Petrof or Weinbach you choose, just avoid the Samick or Y.C. They won't last long until you want another one. I would think a 5-feet baby grand is not much better than a 50' up-right, in terms of sound. And a educated on up-rights, and the ability to adapt to different pianos is a great asset of every pianist.

b rgds/tannie

Cork is basically right, but there is a very small difference in string length as well. Unfortunately, I can't give you specifics, because I don't have specs. here at home.

When all is said and done, buy the one you like, they will both hold up fine.

Richard Galassini Cunningham Piano Co Phila,. Pa. 1 (800) 394-1117 URL:http://www.hometown.aol.com/voce88/cunn.html

Rich,

The speaking length is different? That's news to me. Ivan Kahn told me (nearly six years ago) that the scales were identical. The differences were supposedly just in the plate finishing and cosmetics like the inside rim veneer.

Oh, well; learn something new every day.

Rgds, Cork