My Profile

Keep Up to Date:
Blog RSS
Blog
Forum RSS
Forum
Post New Topic Post Reply
Posted 2 Years, 9 Months ago
limerpharm
Gold Boarder
Posts: 190
graphgraph
User Offline
 
A friend gave me a CD transfer of Japanese EMI/Toshiba LP of WF/BPO '49 Bruckner 7th. The peformance is wonderful and the sound is quite good for the period, reasonably warm and detailed, if somewhat congested in tutti. What I noticed, however, is that during the buildup toward the end of the Adagio, the music sounds as artificially kept at lower volume with a rather sudden crescendo - something absent in WF's '42 recording of that mvt for Telefunken. I wonder if those who know the '49 7th from EMI CD set of Bruckner symphonies (or from Toshiba CD) noticed some evidence of 'gain riding', or if it is just a feature of the Toshiba LP issue. Thanks,
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 2 Years, 9 Months ago
LucaGrella
Gold Boarder
Posts: 207
graphgraph
User Offline
 
Any recording from 1949, especially a recording of a broadcast, is going to have gain riding.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 2 Years, 9 Months ago
eva12
Gold Boarder
Posts: 208
graphgraph
User Offline
 
Agree. But it is part of the job of a good transfer engineer to correct it as much as possible and in a way that does not sound obviously artificial. What happens in that Toshiba LP is that from 14:20 to about 16:20 in the Adagio, the chromatic build up is kept at obviously artificially low volume (relative to the preceding dynamics) only to increase suddenly (and utterly unmusically) at about 16:20. This may not have been a result of the original brodcast, by the way, in which the sound could have been simply compressed (as in WF's '47 live Metamorphosen), but rather some later attempt to create 'dynamical impact'. My ear finds such results far more offensive than just a compressed sound where forte is inferred from increased congestion/distortion of orchestral textures. Since I think that the performance is wonderful, I simply wanted to know if the artificial dynamics of the LP transfer affect also the CD issues. (I don't care, however, about the Urania glassy, fake-stereo hyper-filtered CD abomination.)
The administrator has disabled public write access.
 
Copyright © 2006 - Nov 2008 My Piano Friends